Brian Carnell picks up the "Plagiarism' thread on his own site and poses the question "
Can Computers Detect Internet Cheating?". I agree with Brian about the problems that arise once search engines have indexed tens of billions of web pages. Cheating will become even more endemic than the 60% of (US) students cited by Brian:
A professor I once had held up a newspaper story reporting a poll in which 60 percent of American college students said they had cheated. "What about the other 40 percent?" he asked rhetorically and then quickly answered his own question, "They're liars" which elicited knowing laughter from the class.
The http://plagiarism.org service is an attempt to cash in on the ever-growing issue of academic cheating and they make some bold claims including:
- Increased Quality. Instructors report that the quality of their students' work increases when they know that manuscripts will be checked for originality.
- Heightened Student Morale. Students themselves report that unchecked cheating and plagiarism by others undermines their own efforts and educational enthusiasm.
I have personal experience of the last point. A number of my students each year 'complain' of the demoralising effect that (undetected) cheating by other students have on their own honest and hard-won efforts. I sympathise with them. I suspect that cheating is more widespread than I'd care to admit. That's why I attempt to set assignments that are not so susceptible to what the Americans call the 'fraternity filing-cabinet' problem.
The commercial service of Plagiarism.org is Turnitin.com:
Turnitin.com provides a simple and efficient means for both instructors and students to ensure the originality of their intellectual property. Documents are simply pasted into a text box and uploaded into our protected systems. Within twenty-four hours users receive one of our custom, easy-to-read originality reports detailing the findings of our extensive database and net-wide searches.
Turnit.com seems to me to be geared more towards those subjects where the submitted work is a report or essay. It'd be interesting to see if they have, for instance, indexed pages of program code so that plagiarism of programming assignments can be detected.
Aa an experiment I am considering submitting this document to several of the plagiarism detectors to see if the quoted paragraphs above pin this document down as similar to the plagiarism.org and turnit.com pages from whence they came.
Incidentally, when I quote from a page I used the cite attribute of the <blockquote> tag to pinpoint the source of the quote. Like so:
Incidentally, when I quote from a page I used the cite attribute of the <:blockquote> tag to pinpoint the source of the quote. Like so: <blockquote cite='http://www.smeed.org/678'>Incidentally, when I quote from a page I used the cite attribute of the <blockquote> tag to pinpoint the source of the quote. Like so: </blockquote>
I wouldn't want anyone thinking that I'd plagiarised stuff without crediting the source ;-)
More later perhaps...